diff --git a/docs/tool-reference.md b/docs/tool-reference.md
index 72a41da7c..0e126b8c3 100644
--- a/docs/tool-reference.md
+++ b/docs/tool-reference.md
@@ -215,11 +215,12 @@
 
 ### `performance_analyze_insight`
 
-**Description:** Provides more detailed information on a specific Performance Insight that was highlighted in the results of a trace recording.
+**Description:** Provides more detailed information on a specific Performance Insight of an insight set that was highlighted in the results of a trace recording.
 
 **Parameters:**
 
 - **insightName** (string) **(required)**: The name of the Insight you want more information on. For example: "DocumentLatency" or "LCPBreakdown"
+- **insightSetId** (string) **(required)**: The id for the specific insight set. Only use the ids given in the "Available insight sets" list.
 
 ---
 
diff --git a/src/tools/performance.ts b/src/tools/performance.ts
index 420a62132..a8b24903c 100644
--- a/src/tools/performance.ts
+++ b/src/tools/performance.ts
@@ -121,12 +121,17 @@ export const stopTrace = defineTool({
 export const analyzeInsight = defineTool({
   name: 'performance_analyze_insight',
   description:
-    'Provides more detailed information on a specific Performance Insight that was highlighted in the results of a trace recording.',
+    'Provides more detailed information on a specific Performance Insight of an insight set that was highlighted in the results of a trace recording.',
   annotations: {
     category: ToolCategory.PERFORMANCE,
     readOnlyHint: true,
   },
   schema: {
+    insightSetId: zod
+      .string()
+      .describe(
+        'The id for the specific insight set. Only use the ids given in the "Available insight sets" list.',
+      ),
     insightName: zod
       .string()
       .describe(
@@ -144,6 +149,7 @@ export const analyzeInsight = defineTool({
 
     const insightOutput = getInsightOutput(
       lastRecording,
+      request.params.insightSetId,
       request.params.insightName as InsightName,
     );
     if ('error' in insightOutput) {
diff --git a/src/trace-processing/parse.ts b/src/trace-processing/parse.ts
index 23e195764..cbd79462e 100644
--- a/src/trace-processing/parse.ts
+++ b/src/trace-processing/parse.ts
@@ -97,6 +97,7 @@ export type InsightOutput = {output: string} | {error: string};
 
 export function getInsightOutput(
   result: TraceResult,
+  insightSetId: string,
   insightName: InsightName,
 ): InsightOutput {
   if (!result.insights) {
@@ -105,27 +106,16 @@ export function getInsightOutput(
     };
   }
 
-  // Currently, we do not support inspecting traces with multiple navigations. We either:
-  // 1. Find Insights from the first navigation (common case: user records a trace with a page reload to test load performance)
-  // 2. Fall back to finding Insights not associated with a navigation (common case: user tests an interaction without a page load).
-  const mainNavigationId =
-    result.parsedTrace.data.Meta.mainFrameNavigations.at(0)?.args.data
-      ?.navigationId;
-
-  const insightsForNav = result.insights.get(
-    mainNavigationId ?? TraceEngine.Types.Events.NO_NAVIGATION,
-  );
-
-  if (!insightsForNav) {
+  const insightSet = result.insights.get(insightSetId);
+  if (!insightSet) {
     return {
-      error: 'No Performance Insights for this trace.',
+      error:
+        'No Performance Insights for the given insight set id. Only use ids given in the "Available insight sets" list.',
     };
   }
 
   const matchingInsight =
-    insightName in insightsForNav.model
-      ? insightsForNav.model[insightName]
-      : null;
+    insightName in insightSet.model ? insightSet.model[insightName] : null;
   if (!matchingInsight) {
     return {
       error: `No Insight with the name ${insightName} found. Double check the name you provided is accurate and try again.`,
diff --git a/tests/tools/performance.test.ts b/tests/tools/performance.test.ts
index b8ac55338..0c3cb6584 100644
--- a/tests/tools/performance.test.ts
+++ b/tests/tools/performance.test.ts
@@ -158,6 +158,7 @@ describe('performance', () => {
         await analyzeInsight.handler(
           {
             params: {
+              insightSetId: '8463DF94CD61B265B664E7F768183DE3',
               insightName: 'LCPBreakdown',
             },
           },
@@ -178,6 +179,7 @@ describe('performance', () => {
         await analyzeInsight.handler(
           {
             params: {
+              insightSetId: '8463DF94CD61B265B664E7F768183DE3',
               insightName: 'MadeUpInsightName',
             },
           },
@@ -197,6 +199,7 @@ describe('performance', () => {
         await analyzeInsight.handler(
           {
             params: {
+              insightSetId: '8463DF94CD61B265B664E7F768183DE3',
               insightName: 'LCPBreakdown',
             },
           },