Iteration 3 revision

Issues

• P0: regressions introduced by the revision (S-ME.N1, S-FD.1, S-FD.2, S-AB.N1-N5, S-RE.7-9, ...)

  agent-readyP0review-iter2
  Denolle-Lab/codameter#38 · Filter by author mdenolle opened on Sep 11, 2026 · Iteration 3 revision
  1

• P1: science corrections in results and methods (UQ-05, DET-01, SCI-05, S-RE.2-4, SCI-06/INV-01, ...)

  agent-readyP1review-iter2
  Denolle-Lab/codameter#39 · Filter by author mdenolle opened on Sep 11, 2026 · Iteration 3 revision
  1

• P2: impact and application framing (AUTH-01): sensors as monitors of internal rheology and deformation

  agent-readyneeds-authorP2review-iter2
  Denolle-Lab/codameter#40 · Filter by author mdenolle opened on Sep 11, 2026 · Iteration 3 revision

• P3: provenance, release and real-data figures (REP-02, REP-03, S-RP.1-4, FIG-02, SCI-07)

  agent-readyP3review-iter2
  Denolle-Lab/codameter#41 · Filter by author mdenolle opened on Sep 11, 2026 · Iteration 3 revision
  1

• P4: survey hygiene (S-CD.1-3, SCI-08): Obermann key collision, denominators, reporting rates

  agent-readyP4review-iter2
  Denolle-Lab/codameter#42 · Filter by author mdenolle opened on Sep 11, 2026 · Iteration 3 revision
  1

• P5: register pass over the 40 S-PR candidates

  needs-authorP5review-iter2
  Denolle-Lab/codameter#43 · Filter by author mdenolle opened on Sep 11, 2026 · Iteration 3 revision

• P6: end matter and disclosure (COMP-01, FMT-01 placeholder)

  needs-authorP6review-iter2
  Denolle-Lab/codameter#44 · Filter by author mdenolle opened on Sep 11, 2026 · Iteration 3 revision

• P7: pre-submission reviewer iteration 3 under the denolle profile

  agent-readyP7review-iter2
  Denolle-Lab/codameter#45 · Filter by author mdenolle opened on Sep 11, 2026 · Iteration 3 revision

• Author input: Gate 1 run commit, --use-case, product rights and archive target (blocks P3)

  needs-authorP3review-iter2
  Denolle-Lab/codameter#46 · Filter by author mdenolle opened on Sep 11, 2026 · Iteration 3 revision

• Author input: confirm Yuan et al. (2021) Table B3 estimator ranking (blocks P1, P4)

  needs-authorP1review-iter2
  Denolle-Lab/codameter#47 · Filter by author mdenolle opened on Sep 11, 2026 · Iteration 3 revision
  1

• Author input: verify identical-cell survey rows, the Snieder2002 row and the search rules (blocks P4)

  needs-authorP4review-iter2
  Denolle-Lab/codameter#48 · Filter by author mdenolle opened on Sep 11, 2026 · Iteration 3 revision

• Author decision: keep, trim or drop the composite parameter figure, Fig 8 (blocks P0)

  needs-authorP0review-iter2
  Denolle-Lab/codameter#49 · Filter by author mdenolle opened on Sep 11, 2026 · Iteration 3 revision

• Author decision: replacement for the stacking step-error metric (blocks P1)

  needs-authorP1review-iter2
  Denolle-Lab/codameter#50 · Filter by author mdenolle opened on Sep 11, 2026 · Iteration 3 revision
  1

• P1: science corrections in results and methods (UQ-05, DET-01, SCI-05, S-RE.2-4, SCI-06/INV-01, UQ-03/04)

  P1review-iter2
  Unread
  Denolle-Lab/codameter#52·mdenolle opened Sep 13, 2026 · Updated Sep 14, 2026
  28

• P4: survey hygiene (S-CD.1-3, SCI-08): DOI-aware keys, denominators, coded reporting rates

  P4review-iter2
  Unread
  Denolle-Lab/codameter#53·mdenolle opened Sep 13, 2026 · Updated Sep 14, 2026
  24

• P3 (part 1): sidecar provenance, --check mode, in-repo Gate 1 figure, paper workflow (S-RP.1/3/4, S-RE.5, S-FD.4/5)

  P3review-iter2
  Unread
  Denolle-Lab/codameter#54·mdenolle opened Sep 13, 2026 · Updated Sep 15, 2026
  38